Make like a mirror...

... reflect.

Well, it's that time again. ETL 501 assignments were returned promptly, but I have to admit being a bit disappointed in my result. While 65% is a reasonable pass I thought I'd done enough to warrant slightly better marks on some sections at least. I was a bit confused by the comments. Admittedly, yes I neglected to discuss Boolean logic in my search discussion, and that was a bit of a mistake, but the other comments really didn't match well with what I'd written. Comments on the forum indicate a number of others similarly confused about exactly what they wanted from us, so I'm inclined to think there may have been some harsh marking flying around the place.
My spirits were boosted, however, when I got my ETL 401 assignment back. I don't think I've ever got 98% on an assignment before, and certainly not since I was at school. I can't say I worked  harder on this assignment than the other though, so the discrepancy between the marks is all the more startling. All I can think is that the course notes for 401 gave far more essential and recommended reading throughout, and perhaps I inadvertently spent more time on this than 501. I don't think I could have worked any harder with the time I had available.
So, what lessons can I carry forward? First and foremost, don't bite off more than I can chew. I may have done startlingly well on one assignment, but overall it was a massive struggle to do two subjects whilst working full time and I was just glad to pass. I will be sticking to one subject per semester in future and I might be able to have higher expectations than simply scraping through. For now I'll happily take the marks I've got and prepare to start afresh with ETL 503.

Nothing so nice...

Well, the song says that there's nothing so nice as messing about on the river. However, I just finished reading Thor Heyerdahl's Kon-Tiki Expedition and now have the irresistible urge to spend three months messing about on the Pacific. It's amazing how he makes what almost everyone considered to be a suicide mission sound like the jolliest holiday ever. Just goes to show you should never listen too carefully to the experts.

Unfortunately my wife says I can't spend the next three months floating on a raft across the Pacific. Instead I will be getting stuck into ETL503 Resourcing the Curriculum. The subject outline is available and my first text book has arrived in the post, so there's really no excuse for delay. I just hope that my journey also has lots of interesting fish and not too many storms.

The Evolution of My Views on the TL Role

My initial conception of the role of the teacher librarian was somewhat narrower than it is today. My eyes have been opened, you might say.

I have realised, like Hay and Todd (2010), that this is a profession in the process of change. My initial impression (Farley, 2011a) was that this was something of an ongoing battle between the factions of complacent librarians in situ and emotionally charged researchers, but the House of Representatives report (2011) showed me a profession in crisis, with poor morale and an ageing demographic. I came to realise (Farley, 2011g) that the potential roles of the teacher librarian, as shown by Herring (2007), are too numerous for any one person, and that it is up to those coming in to the profession to choose the roles that will shape the profession for the future.

I think possibly the most challenging role for those coming into the profession is that of technology specialist. Killeen (2009) says that teacher librarians have always led the way with new technology but, as Valenza (2011) demonstrates, technology has been evolving rapidly in recent years. I found this rather overwhelming at first (Farley 2011c), but came to realise that this particular role can be highly enjoyable (Farley, 2011e) and should be embraced. I expressed my concern (Farley, 2011i) that many students only engage in information literacy when they are forced to by teachers, but if it can be incorporated into enjoyable, purposeful projects using this new technology, then it is certainly the role of the teacher librarian to do so.

While I previously familiar with the terms ‘information’ and ‘literacy’ I have to admit that I was unaware they had become conjoined. At no point in my education or teacher training had I been introduced to the term ‘search strategy’ and it was perhaps my first realisation (Farley, 2011f) that the education system is full of teachers and students with self-taught strategies bumbling their way through the information online. Kuiper, Volman and Terwel (2008) point out that we expect primary school students to research online without their having developed any of the critical skills required. Well, we also expect teachers to teach those skills, but we haven’t trained them to do it. I concluded (Farley, 2011d) that my role as a teacher librarian in a primary setting would be to introduce the concept of information literacy to the children early. Rather like learning to read, we need to start off with the basic skills before we can progress to the more advanced tasks. I would add to that the need to develop those skills within the teaching staff also.

Leading on from this, I would now say that it is the role of the teacher librarian to know the students’ needs. Knowing that they are lacking in certain skills gives us the stimulus to implement an information search process model (Wolf 2003). Kuhlthau (2011) focuses on the emotional journey involved in learning something new, and I became aware of my own emotional involvement in the learning process (Farley, 2011b) when reflecting on my first assignment. I know from my own experience working with primary school children how excited they become by a new challenge, and also how quickly some of them will give up and sink into gloom. They are riding an emotional roller coaster and it is certainly the teacher librarian’s role to be aware of what will motivate these students, what they are capable of, and what will support those who feel overwhelmed when faced with challenge.

One of the more surprising changes in my perception of the teacher librarian role has been in connection with their potential as a school leader. Haycock (2007) urges us to be dynamic and extroverted, and my initial reaction was amusement (Farley, 2011h) because this is the antithesis of the commonly held view of teacher librarians. Having now reached the end of this subject I am in agreement with Haycock that the profession needs individuals who can fulfil this role of dynamic leader, and I hope I can do so when the time comes, but I remain concerned that the majority of people attracted to the role of teacher librarian are not extroverts. It will take a prolonged and concerted effort from all involved to change the commonly held conception of someone quietly checking out books all day.

Over the past few months I have been enlightened as to the ideal roles of the teacher librarian. These may not yet entirely match with reality but I am excited to be joining the profession at what could be a new era of heightened respect and job satisfaction as we step out of the library and engage students in authentic, collaborative projects with exciting new technologies designed to meet their individual learning needs. The future looks bright and interesting.

References

Farley, A. (2011a, July 26) Cry Havoc and Let Slip the Librarians of War! [Blog]. Retrieved from http://adamf-anabasis.blogspot.com/2011/07/cry-havoc-and-let-slip-librarians-of.html

Farley, A. (2011b, August 20) Some people are on the pitch… [Blog]. Retrieved from http://adamf-anabasis.blogspot.com/2011/08/some-people-are-on-pitch.html

Farley, A. (2011c, August 26) Cloud Cuckoo Land.[Blog]. Retrieved from http://adamf-anabasis.blogspot.com/2011/08/undiscovered-country.html

Farley, A. (2011d, August 26) Hit ‘em hard and hit ‘em fast. [Blog]. Retrieved from http://adamf-anabasis.blogspot.com/2011/08/hit-em-hard-and-hit-em-fast.html

Farley, A. (2011e, August 29) Hooray for Hollywood! [Blog]. Retrieved from http://adamf-anabasis.blogspot.com/2011/08/hooray-for-hollywood.html

Farley, A. (2011f, July 17) Effective Searching. [Forum comment]. Retrieved from http://forums.csu.edu.au/perl/forums.pl?forum_id=ETL401_201160_W_D_Sub2_forum

Farley, A. (2011g, July 24) Role. [Forum comment].  Retrieved from http://forums.csu.edu.au/perl/forums.pl?forum_id=ETL401_201160_W_D_Sub2_forum

Farley, A. (2011h July 26) Extroverts?  [Forum comment]. Retrieved from http://forums.csu.edu.au/perl/forums.pl?forum_id=ETL401_201160_W_D_Sub2_forum

Farley, A. (2011i, August 29) Transfer.  [Forum comment]. Retrieved from  http://forums.csu.edu.au/perl/forums.pl?forum_id=ETL401_201160_W_D_Sub2_forum

Hay, L. and Todd, R. (2010) School libraries 21C: the conversation begins. Scan, 29(1), pp.30-42.

Haycock, K. (2007) Collaboration: critical success factors for student learning. School  Libraries Worldwide, 13(1), pp.25-35.

Herring, J. (2007) Teacher librarians and the school library. In S. Ferguson (ed.) Libraries in the Twenty-First Century: Charting New Directions in Information, pp.27-42. Wagga Wagga, NSW: Centre for Information Studies, Charles Sturt University.

House of Representatives Standing Committee on Education and Employment (2011), School Libraries and Teacher Librarians in 21^st Century Australia. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia.

Killeen, E.B. (2009) Yesterday, today, and tomorrow: transitions of the work but not the mission. Teacher Librarian, 36(5), pp.8-13.

Kuhlthau, C.C. (2011) Information Search Process. Retrieved 23/08/11 from http://comminfo.rutgers.edu/~kuhlthau/information_search_process.htm

Kuiper, E., Volman, M. and Terwel, J. (2008) Students’ use of web literacy skills and strategies: searching, reading and evaluating web information. Information Research, 13(1) paper 351.

Valenza, J. (2011) See Sally Research (video). Retrieved 2^nd October 2011 from http://tedxphillyed.com/2011/09/video-post-dr-joyce-valenza-see-sally-research/

Wolf, S. (2003) The Big Six Information Skills as a Metacognitive Scaffold: A Case Study. American Library Association. Retrieved 23/08/11 from http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/aasl/aaslpubsandjournals/slmrb/slmrcontents/volume62003/bigsixinformation.cfm

Death to the Collaborators!

Shock horror! After having the importance of teacher/TL collaboration drummed into me by every article I've read over the past 10 weeks I stumbled across a recent article by Michael Eisenberg and Janet Murray, creators of the Big 6.

Eisenberg, M.B. and Murray, J. (2011) Big 6 by the month: a new approach. Library Media Connection, 29(6), pp.10-13 (Can you tell I'm in essay mode?)

I  quote: "Systematic, large-scale, comprehensive collaboration is just not possible given the number of library and technology professionals in most schools."

Well, that's a bit of a shock to a young student like myself. I think I'm suffering from Carol Kuhlthau's uncertainty principle, although I'm not sure if I'm in the Zone of Intervention yet. Can I just hide under a rock until everyone's made up their minds?

Actually, it's not all bad news from the Big 6 twins. They may have thrown collaboration out of the window, but you should still be 'connecting' with the curriculum, and they've put together a month by month programme so that all the TLs will be doing the same things at the same time and can share ideas, plans, etc. That still sounds suspiciously like collaboration to me though.

Time, Time, Time, see what's become of me..

Thank you Mr's Simon and Garfunkel for this week's catchy title. Your royalties are in the post.

I have a vague recollection of reading about time management earlier this week and it all seemed to make some sort of sense at the time. Time, however, is transitory and illusive. I know that time must be managed, but it is rather like herding kittens; you think you've got some time to do something, but before you know it it's gone and you're hunting around after some more.
Nevertheless, time is ticking on and the deadlines for assignments draw ever nearer, so it seems I must shepherd tasks into specific time slots and guard them diligently.

The next assignment for ETL401 is all about information literacy, and I read an interesting piece by some Finnish writers (Tuominen, Savolainen and Talja) who laid a heavy emphasis on the relationship between user and technology as a major part of this topic. Having just left my school and handed in my laptop I have to agree with them. My relationship with my old laptop is extremely strained and I am feeling significantly less information literate with every slow search and internet crash. I joke, of course, but it does highlight to me the need for decent technology access if you are to make use of these skills, which is probably still one of the biggest issues facing teacher libarians, and schools in general, today

The Web of Self-Deceit

I have a child in my class at the moment who is convinced that he is an awesome reader despite the glaring fact that he struggles to read anything longer than  a basic cvc word. The power for self-deceit is quite remarkable.
My readings this week have demonstrated that the Web lends itself to producing a whole generation of students convinced that they are fantastic researchers. After all, they can type what they want into Google and up pop hundreds of results. They can cut and paste to their hearts delight and hey presto... instant assignment. Barely even any need to know what you are researching!
Well, that may be a slight overstatement, but it does not seem to be that far from the truth. Students are over-reliant on Google, inflexible in their approaches to searching, and even those who demonstrate good reading strategies when using print-based text seem to abandon what they have learned when faced with online text. To cap it off they seem to have total faith in everything they see online. The innocence of youth may be sweet and endearing but has no place online.
The alarming fact is that this confidence in their own online infallibility seems to be developing at startlingly early ages. The onus is on those of us engaged in the early years of education to address these issues before the students becpme over-confident and cease listening to reason.
Here I come to save the day...!

Time and Time Again

While the pleasure of further reading on the benefits of collaboration is neverending, what I have taken away from this weeks' readings is that successful collaboration between a teacher and the teacher librarian is massively time-consuming and difficult to achieve, but ultimately worth it. the question I ask myself is that, if it is so difficult to find the time for a single collaboration, how can the teacher librarian possibly find time to effectively collaborate with all members of staff?
Todd recommends a 'Just do it' attitude. (Thank you Nike). I guess if you want it enough you can make it happen..